We Deliver. You Win!
We will find your best offer, guaranteed!

Customers Love MJ Gabel
Just ask the Better
Business Bureau –  A+ Rated

Simple, Effective Process
We handle everything
while keeping you up to date

Trust is Everything
Partnering with you through
this part of your journey

More Options.  Better Results!

Selling your diamonds and jewelry all starts with trust.  The MJ Gabel team has been earning the trust of our clients for more than a decade by dedicating ourselves to serving you and exceeding your highest expectations while at the same time making sure you get the most possible money in the end. Our no-risk or obligation three-step process allows you to earn more money in a way that works best for you and your unique situation all without having to leave the comfort of home.  Click here to get started or call us at (585) 598-1090

However, don’t take our word for it, but let us show you why the Better Business Bureau has awarded MJ Gabel their coveted A+ rating.  Let us share how we have helped clients just like you by selling their diamonds, jewelry, watches and much more.  Earning and maintaining your trust is our number one priority!  Click here to learn more about the MJ Gabel diamond buying process or call us at (585) 598-1090.

MJ Gabel / Advisors & Trustees of Fine Jewelry BBB Business Review

Trusted Reviews

Sophia Castro
15:46 29 Apr 19
Matt Gabel's professionalism is top notch. Knowing you can really trust someone without actually meeting him says a lot about Matt's business and more about him as a person. Integrity, honesty, and respect are some of the few words I would use to describe how Matt represents his business. I shipped one of my diamond rings to another company, but they removed the stone to be able to "take better pictures" and scratched and chip it. I found out about it after they returned it to me because they wouldn't sell it. Matt will treat your jewelry as if it was his. It doesn't matter if it has a value of $1 or $1,000. Once again that tells you a lot about this young man. I recommend that you do business with Matt Gabel. I will guarantee you won't regret it!read more
Jennifer Allegretti Pastore
17:21 19 Feb 19
The first jewelry store I ever had dealings with and felt that I didnt get robbed or done over ... so professional and thorough ... I was happy in every way ... no reservations ... Amazing Service .... I'll never go anywhere else ...read more
Haley Faro
12:33 23 Oct 18
My husband gifted me a watch, that he purchased online, with a link band that needed to be fitted to my wrist. My mom spoke highly of MJ Gabel as she had previous experience with this shop and recommended that I go there. They quickly took care of me, taking out the number of links to my watch band for a good fit and educated me on proper fitting (how a bracelet watch should feel as I never had one before). When it came time for me to leave, they did not charge me for the service and wouldn't even take a tip. So kind! I will be a customer again! Thank you so much!!read more
Rob Shearer
17:32 17 Aug 18
Originally, I purchased a number of diamonds thru vendors I was comfortable with who reside outside the U.S. Sadly, I did so without educating myself beforehand. I was very nervous that I would lose hundreds if not a couple thousand dollars by attempting to sell them myself. I tried other diamond selling websites that turned out to be useless. That was when I came across MJ Gabel Jewelers. After speaking with Matt on the phone for the first few days, I felt comfortable sending him what diamonds I had. There are times in life when one must blindly put their faith & trust in others. For me personally, it rarely turns out to be a good idea. HOWEVER, Matt has worked wonders and I am simply speechless for what he has done for me. Regardless of what type of jewelry or watch I want in the future, I will turn to Matt for all my gemological needs. Truly a top notch jeweler and I think of him as a trusted friend even though we have never met. Thanks for your help and guidance.read more
Suzanne Walzer
13:39 25 Jul 18
My experience with MJ Gabel was excellent. They were very knowledgeable and helped walk me through the process of selling some of my old jewelry. The road outside of their store was undergoing construction, so when I was leaving the owner walked out with me and actually directed traffic so I could get out of their parking lot! Guess where I'll be purchasing MY next piece of jewelry?! 🙂read more
cheri struble
10:26 01 Jun 18
I called for an appraisal of a piece of Jewelry that I recently purchased, and I was able to get my appraisal the same day. The MJ Gabel family are very professional, friendly, and most of all were helpful in relieving my fears. The family is also very knowledgeable in the legalities with purchasing diamonds oversees and companies return policies. I would recommend going there for all your diamond an appraisal needs.read more
Cody Oriel
04:11 26 Nov 17
The MJ Gabel family has helped out in a great way. I went to many other places testing out how the companies would purchase jewlery. I had a good idea of the value of my pieces based on some research i did. First two places i went were far off from expected value. Then i went to mj gabel after more research. They were friendly inviting and addressed all my concerns. They understood how i felt and gave an honest price. They are a very transparent company who seem to hold themselves on integrity. I recommend going to them for purchasing or selling! -2017read more
Michael Kaufman
20:15 03 Jul 17
Matt is VERY professional & knowledgeable. I would highly recommend his business to anyone looking to buy or sell diamonds! They have some magnificent treasures there.
Elizabeth Nelson
18:03 12 Jun 17
I highly recommend MJ Gabel. From beginning to end of selling my jewelry, they gave me time, attention, and knowledge. The process was explained every step of the way with great attention to detail. They did everything to show they were working with my best interests in mind vs. their own interests or profit to them. In fact, while working directly with Matt, he took time to explain and educate me above and beyond. He equipped me in every way with knowledge to help me get the most money for my diamonds. I am impressed and more than satisfied with MJ Gabel's care for clients. Thank you!read more
David Brod
20:37 16 Mar 17
I could not have asked for a better experience. I was selling a ring and had no idea what I was doing. As I began to do research I found most sites seemed a bit "off" or had limited customer service for a process that was so intimidated. MJ Gabel was the exact opposite. Within moments of contacting them for advice I was talking with someone knowledgeable and supportive. Throughout the entire experience I was in constant contact with MJ Gabel and was always felt like I was being treated fairly and had someone who would ensure that I received maximum value for my ring. After all was said and done I did receive maximum value for my ring. I would highly recommend this business to anyone looking to use any of the services. Payment was received quickly and securely.read more
Next Reviews

The MJ Gabel Promise

When a diamond isn’t forever you need an experienced jewelry partner you can trust.  The MJ Gabel Team is made up of a team of talented and skilled diamond and jewelry experts that are focused on helping you earn the most for your jewelry. We will work diligently for you starting with providing you with an accurate jewelry appraisal and working tirelessly to get you the best price for your diamond jewelry.

We Promise You:

  • We provide you with an accurate price range starting with our jewelry appraisal which gives you a true sense of the value of your jewelry from the very beginning of the process. You don’t have to wait for the sale to find out what you’ll make.
  • No hidden fees such as insurance, photography or marketing fees.
  • No surprises. Read our trusted reviews to see what other sellers have experienced.
  • You are in control the entire time. You always maintain ownership of your jewelry until you finalize a sale.
  • We are committed to providing you with a trustworthy and ethical experience.

The MJ Gabel Team will walk with you through the selling process and will ensure the process is a positive and transparent. That is what sets MJ Gabel apart.

Let’s get started today!

The MJ Gabel Promise

When a diamond isn’t forever you need an experienced jewelry partner you can trust.  The MJ Gabel Team is made up of a team of talented and skilled diamond and jewelry experts that are focused on helping you earn the most for your jewelry. We will work diligently for you starting with providing you with an accurate jewelry appraisal and working tirelessly to get you the best price for your diamond jewelry.

We Promise You:

  • We provide you with an accurate price range starting with our jewelry appraisal which gives you a true sense of the value of your jewelry from the very beginning of the process. You don’t have to wait for the sale to find out what you’ll make.
  • No hidden fees such as insurance, photography or marketing fees.
  • No surprises. Read our trusted reviews to see what other buyers have experienced.
  • You are in control the entire time. You always maintain ownership of your jewelry until you finalize a sale.
  • We are committed to providing you with a trustworthy and ethical experience.

The MJ Gabel Team will walk with you through the selling process and will ensure the process is a positive and transparent. That is what sets MJ Gabel apart.

Let’s get started today!
0+
YEARS IN BUSINESS.
ONE CLIENT AT A TIME
0M
VALUE OF PIECES
SOLD FOR CLIENTS
0%
HIGHER PRICE DELIVERED
TO CLIENTS
0
INDIVIDUALS & FAMILIES HELPED OVER OUR LIFETIME
0
WORKING WITH CLIENTS
FROM ALL 50 STATES

10+

YEARS IN BUSINESS. ONE CLIENT AT A TIME

38M

VALUE OF PIECES SOLD FOR CLIENTS

35%

HIGHER PRICE DELIVERED TO CLIENTS

13,800

INDIVIDUALS & FAMILIES HELPED OVER OUR LIFETIME

50

WORKING WITH CLIENTS FROM ALL 50 STATES

Our Story

When it comes to selling diamond jewelry the MJ Gabel team expect clients to make an intelligent decision based on their personal objectives. MJ Gabel is a brick & mortar family-owned national jewelry store dedicated to your complete satisfaction. The selling process we created is designed to educate you about your diamond jewelry, while seamlessly offering you an intelligent price based upon an accurate and precise jewelry appraisal. Our extensive experience and unparalleled market knowledge allows you to make an empowered choice that is tailored to your individual needs.

Some of Our Current Collection

Ready To Learn More?
Call (585) 598-1090

Request a Quote

Want to know more about our process? Click here.